With ecommerce burgeoning in the region, Souqalmal.com thought it would be an interesting experiment to buy exactly the same item from three different online shopping sites, Koorabazar.com, Namshi.com and Souq.com, and compare the cost, ease and speed of delivery, return and refund or exchange in the UAE.
The item we bought? A pair of men’s Puma Evopower TT trainers, size 43.
Table 1: The results
Koorabazar.com | Namshi.com | Souq.com | |
Cost | 232 AED | 290 AED | 232 AED * |
Delivery cost | free | free | 12 AED |
Ease of order | Must register fully before ordering | Can check out with just an email address | Must register but pre-fill via Facebook info. Needed both email and mobile confirmation codes to complete |
Usually ships in | 2 – 3 working days | 1 -2 working days | 3 – 7 working days (next day if ordered before 10am) |
Speed of delivery | 45 hours, 23 mins | 45 hours, 15 mins | 42 hours, 36 mins |
Ease of return | Took several hours to get through to call center – order identified via mobile number | Called call center – order identified via mobile number | Called call center – order identified via mobile number. Quickest of the three calls |
Speed of return | Picked up in 2 working days | Picked up in 2 working days | Picked up in 4 working days |
Ease of refund/ exchange | No refund. Koorabazar.com took a further 24 hours to issue an exchange voucher, in order for to confirm no damage to shoes once returned | No refund. Voucher emailed around five hours after shoes picked up | Refund still had not been made at time of going to press, four working days later (should take up to six working days) |
* Sold from KooraBazar.com as a retailer on Souq.com
Table 2: Souqalmal.com’s Scores (5 high, 1 low)
Koorabazar.com | Namshi.com | Souq.com | |
Total cost | 5 | 2 | 4 ** |
Ease of order | 3 | 5 | 3.5 |
Speed of delivery | 4 | 4.5 | 5 |
Ease of return | 2 | 3 | 3.5 |
Speed of return | 4 | 4 | 2.5 |
Refund/ exchange | 2 | 2 | 4 |
Total | 20/30 (67%) | 20.5/ 30 (68%) | 22.5/ 30 (75%) |
** Same cost as bought direct from Koorabazar.com but with additional delivery cost
Comments
- Special mention – Koorabazar.com actually spotted we had ordered the same item directly and via Souq.com and took the time to call and check we really wanted this.
- No site has a full online return service like, say, Amazon.
- Souq.com took four working days just to pick up the item and refund still had not been made at time of going to press, six days (four working days) later.
- Souq.com was the only site to charge for delivery… but is also the only one to give a refund rather than just a voucher for exchange.
- Even with exchange vouchers there were differences – Koorabazar.com took significantly longer than Namshi.com because they checked the returned item before issuing a voucher.
- It’s worth noting, too, that the cost has since significantly dropped on Koorabaaar.com – now down to 174 AED, which changes the game dramatically!
And online shopping elsewhere?
- Registering: Many ecommerce sites still require full registration too but generally sites now only *need* an email address to log in or a social media account to pull your details into a registration page.
- Cash on delivery: Pretty much unheard of, but using credit cards online is standard and very widely accepted in the US, UK, Europe etc.
- Courier v post: To keep costs down/ delivery free, most sites abroad use local postal services – which of course don’t exist in the GCC. But you always have the option to pay more for next-day or even same-day delivery. Using post is easier too, as you don’t have to be at home in order for many items to be delivered. But as you don’t generally know exactly what time your delivery is arriving, there can often be a very annoying trek to the local post office to pick up your parcel on a weekend. Talking of weekends – Amazon has even introduced Sunday deliveries in the UK.
- Refunds: So much simpler elsewhere! Not getting a full refund is virtually unheard of and the refund generally arrives within the week. If you want to speed things up, you can often get the money credited, e.g. into your Amazon account, if you’re a regular online shopper.
Verdict
If you know exactly what you want and are sure you want it, shop around with different online shopping sites and go by the best price. Otherwise, pay the delivery charge with Souq.com, thereby getting the option of a full refund. But there’s still a little way to go before Middle East online shopping gets as simple as in the West…
Table 3: Full comparison details
Site | Koorabazar.com | namshi.com | souq.com * |
From their site | |||
Who? | The largest football e-shop in the Middle East’ | The Middle East’s most happening online destination for fashion and footwear’ | The ” Amazon of the ME” |
Delivery cost | Free across GCC (above 200 AED in UAE, otherwise 20 AED cost) | Free across UAE | 12 AED |
Cash on delivery charge | 5 AED | 15 AED | 4 AED |
Usually ships in | 2 – 3 days inside UAE; 5 – 7 working days elsewhere in GCC | 1 – 2 working days | 3 – 7 working days; next day if ordered before 10am |
Return | Request must be made (by email or phone) to return item within 14 working days of delivery | Request must be made (by email or phone) to return item within 14 days of delivery | Request must be made (by phone or email or contact form online) to return item within 3 days of delivery |
Fine print | In fully re-saleable condition, with all original packaging | You can return any unworn merchandise in resalable condition. Please ensure all original tags, labels, and packaging are intact | The item(s), any related accessories and/or tools and components – along with the original packaging – is in the original state and condition when purchased and received. For any Souq fashion purchase(s) you get an extended return policy up to 14 days from date of delivery |
Refund | no | no | yes |
Exchange | yes | yes | yes |
Delivery cost refunded | no | na | no |
The order | |||
Order link | http://www.koorabazar.com | https://en-ae.namshi.com/buy-puma-evopower-4-tt-for-men-football-shoes-66044.html | http://uae.souq.com/ae-en/puma-evopower-4-turf-size-40-eu-10295501-6795618/i/ |
Ordered | 05/05/2014 15:46 | 05/05/2014 15:22 | 05/05/2014 16:40 |
Cost (AED) | 232 | 290 | 232 |
Shipping cost | 0 | 0 | 12 |
Total cost | 232 | 290 | 244 |
Ease of order | Must register fully | Can check out using just email address | Must register but pre-fills with Facebook info. Must receive and reconfirm with both email and mobile codes |
The delivery | |||
Ease of delivery | Aramex text message 1011am 06/05/14. Logged onto Aramex 1322 and asked for delivery Wed 07/05/14 10:00 – 14:00 | KB called at 18:43 to check we meant to order twice! | |
Delivery date and time | 07/05/2014 13:09 | 07/05/2014 12:37 | 07/05/14, called 10:27, arrived 11:16 |
Duration from order to delivery | 45 hours, 23 mins | 45 hours, 15 mins | 42 hours, 36 mins |
The return/ exchange/ refund | |||
Request to return made | 08/05/2014 | 08/05/2014 | 08/05/2014 |
Return date and time | 12/05/2014 16:25 | 12/05/2014 14:58 | 14/05/2014 14:48 |
Duration to pick up item from request time | 2 working days | 2 working days | 4 working days |
Ease of refund | Called customer service but the number kept going to voicemail over two hours (only one out of three without dedicated call center). To return the package, all they asked for is your mobile number to know which product was purchased | Called call center to return the product; mobile number was enough to identify order. Explained voucher process | Called call center to return the product; very quick to identify order and set up return using mobile number. Even though the policy said 14 days for fashion items, it turned out to be three days only for shoes |
Refund | No – voucher emailed but only after Koorabazar.com checked that returned item was not damaged (24 hours) | No – voucher emailed some 5 hours after calling again to confirm package had been picked up | Refund 4 – 6 days after return onto card ** |
Exchange voucher received | 13/05/2014 16:29 | 12/05/2014 19:43 | na |
Duration from pick-up to voucher | 24 hours, 4 mins | 4 hours, 45 mins | na |
* Sold from KooraBazar.com as a retailer on Souq.com
** Same cost as bought direct from Koorabazar.com but with additional delivery cost